| A Recollection: Rufus Shaw On Race |
|
|
|
| by Scott Bennett | Wed, Mar 12, 2008, 10:55 PM |
|
The bark is off the tree. America’s first black President, Bubba Bill, is now seen as a race baiter for correctly noting that Sen. Obama’s recollections of his Iraq war opposition were a “fairy tail.” The nation’s first and only female candidate for Vice President, Geraldine Ferraro, is being blasted as a racist for correctly suggesting that if Sen. Obama were white he wouldn’t be taken seriously as a candidate. Sen. Obama’s minister, Rev. Jeremiah Wright, Jr., is in hot water for correctly stating that “Sen. Clinton has never been called a nigger.” ( I have heard her called much worse.) It is going to only get worse.. The nation’s current racial dialogue was the subject of an essay I was writing for another Blog when I received an email from Sam Merten that Rufus Shaw had killed himself and his wife. I was carried back to the time I first met Rufus Shaw, the only time I had a lengthy and serious talk with him. It was all about race and it was a revelation. We met one evening in the early 1980s (I don’t recall the exact year) at Cardinal Puffs, a now extinct SMU beer garden. I was with a group of friends. Rufus knew someone in our crowd and joined us. As time wore on Rufus and I found ourselves alone and drifted into a discussion I preferred not to have. The young black man I recall was, to say the least, full of himself. .He was swagger, bravado and flamboyance. He was intimidating and intended to be. But he was also articulate, incredibly smart, incredibly well-read, and insightful. In short the man had charisma. Rufus started off talking about a book he had recently written. I asked if he had a copy. He vanished to his car and returned shortly with an autographed copy of How to Be a Rich Nigger. I read the cover and my face fell off. Shaw snorted “You’re turning white.” “Uh, I am white.” “I am talking about what white people turn when confronted with real black,” he retorted. I spent the next couple of hours listening as Rufus Shaw explained his version of black and white. “You have no idea what it is like to be black,” he told me. “Not the poorest white trash born can understand let along some guy like you.” I protested. “Don’t give me that s**t. You can’t even imagine.” “OK, I challenged, “explain it to me.” “When your black it doesn’t matter how smart you are, or how educated, you keep thinking you always got more to prove. If you’re black and you fall there’s going to be no one to catch you.” Shaw told me there were four types of black people. There were the “Oreos” (his word) who were culturally white and had lost all touch with their blackness. He didn’t begrudge these people their success, but was sure it wasn’t a price he would pay. This group he said “loved everything about white people.” The second group he called African-Americans. These were like Italian-Americans. They were proud to be black but moved with confidence and authority in a white world while remaining black. He was convinced white folks were terrified of the African-American. They shouldn’t be he said; African-Americans merely resented white people but had what it takes to beat them at their own game. The third type he called “black folks.” These were the segregated that lived in a rich black culture but who were outsiders from the larger America. I’ll never forget his words: “All black folks hate white folks. But they know they have to live with them so they act respectful. They shouldn’t; they should let it hang out.” The fourth were what whites would call the underclass of gang bangers and druggies. I asked Rufus if he hated white people. “I haven’t decided yet,” he answered looking me very square in the eyes. What Rufus Shaw believed in was politics. He said the political world was the only world that offered redemption for blacks. “Until we have political power the white world will pay us no mind. They’ll pay us to behave or deliver or whatever, but we’ll have no respect, no equality, until we hold real power, until they have to ask us permission.” Rufus Shaw and I only occasionally ran into each other over the years. We usually engaged in brief polite conversation. After Tom Pauken recruited him to write for Dallas Blog Rufus and I chatted at Tom’s house once. It was inane prattle. It was the only time I met his wife. He had just turned 50. The bravado and swagger were gone but the keen mind remained. I wanted to ask him how or if his views had changed over a quarter century but somehow it didn’t seem fair. As he wrote for Dallas Blog I was continuously asked by readers if other blacks actually believed as Shaw did. I would always say I didn’t really know. But I do know Rufus convinced me black and white America are like parallel universes. If nothing else, the campaign of Barack Obama is going to give white Americans their first real view of another world just down the street. (NOTE: Obviously, I am quoting Rufus Shaw from a 25-year old memory and the words are doubtless inexact. But the representation of his thoughts are very accurate. Rufus Shaw made a hell of an impression.)
Bookmark
Email This
Comments (26)
![]()
...
written by gbc , March 13, 2008 This is a wonderful recollection. I'm sure "the real Deal" would have loved it and commented - just not sure what he'd say??? I am black?? I love this blog!
...
written by Jackson , March 13, 2008 White Americans are always whistlling past the graveyard when it comes to race. You are right on. Whites are about to learn what the big divide is really all about.
...
written by equiltynotrevenge , March 13, 2008 Excellent!! Honest is the only way to go. Even if its just Rufus opinion or in fact, fact its better than the politcally correct wite run media puts out
...
written by equiltynotrevenge , March 13, 2008 please excuse my rushed above post and feel free to omit it with this more coherent piece in its place Excellent HOnesty is the only way to go Even if its just Rufus' opinion, or in fact, fact, it is better than the dribble the politically correct media puts out
...
written by Jackson , March 13, 2008 Rufus Shaw told Mr. Bennett a truth whites don't want to hear: Blacks see the world different. They have not one lick of respect for whites. They don't trust whites. They look at history and see what white people have done to them and so they find it easy to believe whites created AIDS or crack to keep them down. White people says lets leave all that in the past and just get along. We say you owe us big time. You don't want to hear that. You think Rev. Jeremiah is a radical and racist black power man. He speaks loud and clear to black folks. He is right Hillary ain't every been called a nigger. Black folks don't want a proxy president like Bubby or Hillary. They want a real black man. THey weren't sure that was Sen. Barack but when they hear Rev. Jeremiah talkin trash the believe. That is what I mean.
...
written by A black friend of Scotts. , March 13, 2008 Scott let me explain why whatever you have heard Hillary Clinton called it can't compare to "nigger." When a white person uses the word "nigger" they are telling a black person that they are lower than animals. They are saying that a black person exists to be a beast of burden, to be lynched, to be whipped, to be starved and it is all OK with God and man. That's what nigger means. All those names Hillary has been called may reflect on her judgment, her morals, her honor, her personality. But they accept she is a human being not 3/5ths of a human being. Hillary has never faced a life where shining shoes or doing white folks laundry was the best she could aspire to. You and I know each other so I know that you have at least an inkling of the difference. Maybe brother Shaw helped you understand. But you also know you can't really know until you have walked a mile in our shoes. You haven't. You are an upper middle class white boy born to a well connected family. Maybe you have had your ups and downs but there was always a very big net to catch you. That wasn't there for brother Shaw.
...
written by S. Davis , March 13, 2008 Jackson, I do not doubt that racism exists in America or anywhere else, and I do believe that great strides still need to be made in order to assure equality among all Americans. But it is words like yours that frighten whites such as myself. I am not afraid of equal blacks (or any other race). I am afraid, however, of blacks who give the impression that equality would not be enough; that even if blacks enslaved whites that it would not be enough. It sounds to me that no matter what white people (who had no part in the atrocities of the past) do today, it will not be enough. It is attitudes like yours that make me fear individuals like yourself; not for my own sake but for the future of my children who should have every opportunity to succeed in life as your children regardless of their skin color or the skin color of their parents.
...
written by 2cents , March 13, 2008 TJ, it's all about the next big battle between blacks and whites - REPARATIONS for slavery, for being held down by the white man, decades and decades of racism . . . or, it's all about another free handout . . . in cash.
...
written by TJ , March 13, 2008 And I'm sorry...where you you enslaved? What plantation? Well, I guess that doesn't really matter. I guess what matters is I didn't have ONE single ancestor here in the states until 1903, which if you didn't skip that day of history class, was 62 years AFTER the end of the Civil War. So, again...I pose the question...What do I owe ANYONE? I owe people respect when they offer an EQUAL amount of respect. Ever heard the phrase, "Those who live in the past are doomed to repeat it?"
...
written by equiltynotrevenge , March 13, 2008 If you want people to fear you THEN YOU'LL NEVER GET RESPECT. Now think about the difference between fear and respect. If your feared, business wont open up to you or first chance they get, they will fire you. everything will be based on handouts and no (self) respecting human wants to live that way. The only way fear will have you obtain anything, ends up getting you thrown in jail and then the cycle keeps repeating itself. And then the "otherside" ( of bill Cosby etc) says look, they are keeping themselves down. The time has come to drop the dishonesty. Hasnt Mr. Shaws death taught us at least that?
...
written by ph balanced , March 13, 2008 It's true enough that we all grow more mellow with age, and we gain higher and common understanding. Do the race issues of today mirror the issues of 25 years ago? Much regarding race relations has changed - and we've all adapted with this change. Given time and tide, most know and understand this community reality. Two other questions come to mind: one, who are our authentic Dallas "black" political progressive leaders of today? Second, would Rufus have classified, looking through his own lens view of 25 years ago or today, Obama as "oreo", "african-american" or "black"? In 2000 when Obama got trounced in the US Congressional Dem primary against an incumbent (a former Black Panther), Obama's campaign and rhetoric was far more about touting his Harvard education and he was sharply condemned by the Chicago area black community on the basis of his very white lifestyle and his apparent disconnection from being even remotely "african-american" or "black" (translated according to Shaw's definitions). So, are we to conclude (by today's terms) that Obama, with a multi-million dollar house and private school educated children, that he is the empowered "black" political candidate Shaw hoped for? [Bubba Bill and Hillary both have been working for the black community as uniters since the beginning.] Why does or should Senator Obama automatically get the automatic support of the black community over Senator Clinton - when such support seems to resonate because of the color of his black white skin (something none of us has any real control over)? Our loss of Rufus means we will not, for-never more, have the opportunity to dialogue with him on these and other important questions of race and common understanding. Moreover, what is it to be deemed "white" anymore? What happens if you are the product of white plus one or two or more minority races? What happens if you happen to be half black and half hispanic? Is it OK to be gay? Given so many interracial marriages along with widespead cultural and social shifts in the last 25 years, there has been a widespead mixing up of races and ethnicities, which complicates matters all the more. Wasn't Martin Luther King more concerned with the content of a man's character, not the color of his skin (nor one's sex, faith, or sexual orientation)? Moreover, given the raw numbers of today, more hispanics struggle with race inequality than any other ethnic group. Seems the only 'fairy tale' (that's tale, not tail) is the one about any one minority or majority group deserving (or taking) more political power over another group, because of some past inequity. It is hard to know who is who anymore and it is not helpful to assume that the color of your skin automatically requires you to belong/identify with one group over another. Those who are impoverished face the ultimate discrimination; but in the face of such discrimination it is our freedom gives us all the ability to overcome. Think about it. RIP Rufus. You are most certainly missed.
...
written by TJ , March 14, 2008 Very well said, ph balanced. That has to be one of the most educated things said on this site that I've read! I applaud you on your insight! Thank you for sharing such rational, meaningful thoughts!
...
written by Cap Miller , March 14, 2008 Can someone answer this for me: At what point does a man become a "black man?" Obama is half white and half black so what makes him "black" instead of "white?"
...
written by JBR , March 14, 2008 Here is what I have learned... If I say, I look past a person's color, then people tell me that I am naive or a liar. If I notice a person's color or culture as being different, even if it is a positive way, then I am a closet racist. It seems to me that I (notice I didn't include or lump myself together with my race?... it seems that I can't win for losing. So what's funny is... it doesn't matter that my grandfather is Native American and my grandmother is black. It doesn't matter if my father is hispanic, and my mother is half Native American/African American and half white, what matters to everyone is the fact that I look more white. Nobody asks me how I feel. No one cares that I may feel closer to being black than white or vice versa. Blacks don't accept me because I'm not black enough, Native Americans don't accept me because I am not Indian enough, and Hispanics don't accept me even though I speak Spanish better than most of them. In my search over the last forty years of trying to find a culture to belong to, it has only been the whites who have accepted me without flinching, even thought I don't exactly look white. I have never had a problem with being accepted by whites. Does racism exist? Sure! But I will tell you in my opinion, it is perpetuated more by minorites than it does by whites now days. Everyone is searching for an excuse for their lot in life. No one wants to take control or responsibility for their actions. Rufus - I am sorry that he is gone. He filled a needed niche. However, I think his attitude was just as bad, and just as irresponsible, and just as racist as those whites he was condemning. What's worse is that he has a following who believe exactly as he does. We are not allowed to lump or group all African Americans together, because there are all types, but all I hear lately is Blacks lumping all Hispanics together or all whites together. My black friends seem to be more intolerant than any other race I have had the experience of knowing. They tend to hide it around me, our white friends, or our hispanic or asian friends, but I hear what they say. My point is that everyone needs to stop pointing fingers and realize that the more naive people we have about race the better. We don't need finger pointers. We need people who really do look beyond a person;s color. When blacks stop looking at themselves as black, and whites stop looking at themselves as white, then isn't that better? Why wouldn;t I want to be naive about race. To me, being naive about race shows a beginning of the end of racial division, but when people try to force my eyes wide open, then all that is happening is that I begin to actually see the lines dividing each race, whereas before the lines were invisible.
...
written by Jackson , March 14, 2008 Obama was raised by his "white" middle class mother. He never experienced what a black man experiences growing up in the south side of Chicago, Harlem or Watts. Obama has had a priviledged life.
...
written by BettyCulbreath , March 14, 2008 Rufus and I would have very heated debates about race .I am black and 66 years old. JBR is correct Blacks and Hispanics keep the racial divide going and Whites are afried of both. I will miss my friend ,SHAW as he loved being called. On Obama vs. Hillary I would vote Obama because I know John McCain very well and I do not want a repeat of the last Clinton White House. One thing I can say and I will not use the R-word , I have worked in 11 Presidential campaigns and have never had the typs of question being ask of a candidate as being ask Obama. Not even in the Jesse Jackson camp I worked in 1988. (correct any word misspelled)
...
written by Cap Miller , March 15, 2008 Jackson, not all blacks live in Watts, Harlem or Southside. Those who live elsewhere might question your statement that blacks not living in those iconic black neighborhoods makes them "priveleged." My original point was that, physically at least, Obama is as much white as he is black; but black is what we see and black is what makes him noteworthy in this election. Geraldine Ferraro was right: If he were white, or at least viewed as white, he wouldn't be in the running for the nomination.
...
written by equiltynotrevenge , March 15, 2008 It was in fact blacks who first said that Obama was not black enough so that was actually the first notion of race in this contest. NO one group is more racist than others; take individual responsibility for your actions and that is who is racist or non racist.
...
written by Harley , March 15, 2008 It seems to me that the views expressed by Jackson represent exactly why a true meeting of the minds about race relations is highly unlikely, here or anywhere else. Non-black observers perceive that underlying anger and resentment toward whites, and realize that they are just being naive in thinking that they can have a balanced conversation about racial equality. We read in the news about the immigrant Vietnamese couple who wanted to run a liquor store in Dallas and make a better life for themselves and their family, only to be robbed, beaten and ultimately paralized or killed by (presumably) young men who don't share a view about the sanctity of life. Young black men have been arrested and charged with the murders of young white women, and we can only shake our heads about the senselessness of it all. Jackson would most likely retort that these are isolated situations and it's unfair to blame all young black men as criminals. Or, maybe we should blame lack of education, jobs, broken homes, drugs, etc., for why young people do harm to others. At the end of it all, the commenter above hit the nail on the head. If it's true that "all black folks hate white folks", as Scott remembered hearing from Rufus, that only reinforces a gut level fear many whites have about blacks, especially young black males. Jackson thinks we "owe" blacks "big time". He's correct that "we don't want to hear that". Many whites think that that attitude is exactly what's wrong with race relations. Blacks thinking there is a debt that is owed, and whites thinking that the solution can only be found by blacks themselves. Blacks picking themselves up by their bootstraps and staying in school to get educations so they could get better jobs, black men stopping getting black women pregnant out of marriage, black women stopping their believe that having babies gives them status, blacks turning away from gangs and getting back to the principles that Martin Luther King thought worthwhile. I hate to think that conversations I have had with black friends about these tough issues were always just the naive longing for understanding by my misguided liberal views of the world, and that those friends were really just laughing to themselves at my naivete. I think that Jackson's views represent a festering sore that is always waiting for its scab to be pulled off. Rufus, RIP.
...
written by Nobody's fool , March 17, 2008 Betty, What "questions" are you referring to? The questions being asked of Obama are necessary because he is a candidate without much of a record. If anything, the press has not gone far enough, or detailed enough on Obama's past and the nature of his political and business relationships. When there is not a public trail of information, it is the duty of the press to get the full disclosure. Senator Clinton has been put under every microscope, as has Senator McCain. Both have very open to address their records directly, and both have visible public records, which is in stark contrast to Obama, who still has not adequately and completely answered concerning his relationship with Rezko and others. It ironic that Obama uses the very same Senate voting records against Clinton and McCain while shielding himself from the same scrutiny (given his own thin and non-controversial Senate voting record). Candidates today are more than well aware of the notion that if you cannot take the heat, get out of the kitchen... What do you have against Senator Clinton?
...
written by Willy , March 18, 2008 Start the discussion when someone can point to the positive aspects of African-American culture...something other than rap, fatherless families, and success through drug-dealing and professional sports. Shaw talked nothing but sh** and then killed his wife and himself...what a tribute to success.
...
written by De , March 18, 2008 The death of rufus and Lynn shaw is still a mistery. Who has the answer? WHEN WILL THE INVESTIGATION BE FINISH, THEY TOOK THE COMPUTER BY NOW WE SHOULD KNOW IMMEDIATELY LIKE THEY TOOK THE COMPUTER IMMEDIATELY. WHAT'S THE ANSWER?
...
written by Jonathan Green , March 19, 2008 In the analogoy Rufus passed down to you, I would suppose I fall in the line a black folks, although today, at 49 years of age, I can truely say, I don't hate white folks. Earlier in my younger days I suppose I was a hater, however, the more educated you become, and through the experiences of life you encounter, at some point my views changed as result of being helped along the way by generous white folks that were loving in spirit. I sort of agree with Rufus's perception, we talked on the phone, and he would educated on some things, growing up in South Dallas, I admired him for his intellect, how good he was in sports, and the days of masquerading with as a wantabe, in the I want to be down era of parliment funkadelic. Nevertheless, I agree with Mr. Shaw that, “When your black it doesn’t matter how smart you are, or how educated, you keep thinking you always got more to prove. If you’re black and you fall there’s going to be no one to catch you.” When you are black and you fall, the haters and so call friends disappear, assasinating your character, degrading your family, so true as it maybe, I often now wonder if this is what propel Rufus to react the way he did in his final days.
...
written by Ace Boone , March 21, 2008 Jackson is right.Infamous examples of real racism in the past such as the Tuskegee Syphilis Study (1932-1972) have injured the level of trust in the black community towards public health efforts and white people.The AIDS epidemic has exposed the Tuskegee study as a historical marker for the legitimate discontent of blacks with the public health system.The belief that AIDS is a form of genocide is rooted in recent experiences of racism.The theories range from the belief that the government promotes drug abuse in black communities to the belief that HIV is a manmade weapon of racial warfare.But I don't hate all white people and I don't like all black people. Write comment
|
|
| Next > |
|---|























